An impact wrench delivers high torque in short hammer-and-anvil bursts, which makes it the right choice for breaking loose stuck fasteners and removing lug nuts. An air ratchet turns with a ratchet mechanism at lower torque and higher speed, which makes it better for running fasteners in tight spaces once they are loose, and for lighter assembly. Neither tool is a torque wrench, so finish critical fasteners with one.
How Each Tool Makes Torque
An impact wrench uses a motor to spin a weighted hammer. The hammer strikes an anvil on the output shaft, and each strike delivers a burst of torque. That burst is what breaks loose a fastener that has seized.
An air ratchet uses a ratchet gear and pawl. The motor turns the drive in one direction with a ratcheting action. There is no hammer strike, so the output is steadier and easier to control, but it delivers less torque.
Torque and Speed
Impact wrenches generally deliver more torque than air ratchets, and air ratchets generally run faster. Torque ratings differ widely by model, and manufacturers do not always measure them the same way. When you compare tools, use figures from the same brand or the same test method where possible. Do not assume a tool’s category sets its torque, because models vary.
Air Use
Impact wrenches generally use more air than air ratchets. Check each tool’s air use, usually given as CFM at 90 PSI, and compare it with your compressor’s output. If you run both at the same time, add their figures. For sizing help, see choosing an air compressor for auto mechanic work.
Size, Weight and Reach
Air ratchets tend to have a smaller head and lower weight, which helps in tight engine bays and under dashboards. Impact wrenches are heavier and need more room around the fastener. They also produce more vibration and noise. Compare the length and head size of each tool with the space you actually have to work in.
Which to Use for Common Jobs
| Job | Better choice | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Removing lug nuts | Impact wrench | Breaks loose tight nuts quickly |
| Seized suspension or axle bolts | Impact wrench | High torque bursts break them free |
| Running off a bolt once it is loose | Air ratchet | Faster, with more control |
| Working in a tight engine bay | Air ratchet | Smaller head and lighter weight |
| Tightening to a specification | Torque wrench | Neither air tool gives precise, repeatable torque |
| Light assembly where low torque is enough | Air ratchet or hand tool | Less torque is needed, and control matters |
Final Tightening and Torque Accuracy
Neither air tool is a torque wrench. An impact wrench’s pulses can overtighten a fastener, stretch a bolt or damage threads. Even an air ratchet can overtighten if you hold the trigger. For wheel lug nuts and any fastener with a torque specification, finish with a torque wrench set to the vehicle’s specification, and follow the sequence in the service information.
Sockets and Safety
- Use impact-rated sockets with an impact wrench. Standard chrome sockets can crack or shatter under impact, and the pieces can strike you.
- Match the drive size. Use impact-rated extensions and adapters for the same reason.
- Make sure the socket is fully seated on the fastener and retained on the drive by its pin or detent.
- Wear eye protection. Fasteners and broken parts can fly loose.
- Secure the hose. A pressurized hose can whip if it comes loose or kinks at the tool.
- Keep hands clear of the socket and the fastener when the tool is running.
Cordless Alternatives
Cordless impact and ratchet tools can be a good option where a compressor is impractical. Compare torque, weight and battery run time for the job, rather than assuming a category will match an air tool’s performance. Air tools still avoid battery limits, which can matter on long jobs. For a general look at the tools a compressor can run, see examples of tools that use compressed air.
For how these tools produce torque internally, see how air tools work.